Falling Premiums, Rising Risks: Why Australian Businesses Should Make the Most of Today's Insurance Market

The insurance market

Australian businesses are paying less for commercial insurance, even as the cost of settling claims continues to rise. This growing gap raises questions about how long favourable market conditions can continue and what businesses should consider before their next insurance renewal.

According to Aon's Q3 2026 Global Insurance Market Insights Report1, Australian insurance pricing decreased by high-single digits overall during the third quarter of 2026. Property insurance recorded even greater double-digit reductions, while casualty, cyber and directors and officers insurance also experienced lower pricing.

Strong competition and abundant insurer capacity have created opportunities for businesses to secure lower premiums, broader coverage and improved policy terms. However, declining premiums do not necessarily reflect a reduction in the underlying cost of risk.

Claims inflation remains a concern, particularly in long-tail liability classes where claims can take years to resolve. Higher labour and material costs are increasing the cost of settling claims, while supply chain and geopolitical pressures are adding further complexity.

The Pacific region experienced relatively few major natural catastrophe losses during Q3, helping to reduce claims volatility. However, the cost of existing claims has continued to rise, while insurers have adopted more detailed approaches to claims assessment and coverage decisions.

This combination of claims inflation and soft market pricing is putting pressure on insurers. While competition continues to benefit businesses, sustained pricing reductions could become more difficult to maintain if claims costs remain elevated.

Australia's insurance market continues to benefit from strong insurer balance sheets and abundant capacity. Against this backdrop, the current pricing trajectory is unlikely to change materially in the near term. However, businesses should consider how they can make the most of current conditions rather than assume similar opportunities will always be available.

Pricing trends also vary across insurance classes. While property insurance has experienced substantial reductions, commercial automobile insurance recorded increases of 1% to 10% during Q3, reflecting higher repair costs and claims pressures. Insurers also continue to assess businesses according to their claims histories, risk management practices and exposure to natural catastrophes.

For businesses approaching renewal, the priority should be reviewing the quality of their insurance arrangements, not simply the premium.

Coverage limits are one area worth examining. Rising construction, labour and replacement costs can increase the financial consequences of a loss. A policy that provided adequate protection several years ago may no longer reflect the cost of repairing or replacing damaged assets.

Businesses should also review their policy terms, exclusions and deductibles. Strong competition is creating opportunities to negotiate broader coverage and higher limits. In property insurance, some buyers have secured the reinstatement of coverage restricted during the previous hard market, along with improvements to policy wording and sub-limits.

The current market also provides an opportunity to consider the quality of insurer relationships. Lower premiums may deliver immediate savings, but an insurer's financial strength, claims performance and ability to manage complex losses can have a greater impact when a major claim occurs.

Strong risk management remains important in securing favourable renewal outcomes. Insurers are increasingly using data and analytics to assess individual risks. Businesses that provide accurate exposure information, demonstrate effective controls and maintain strong claims histories are more likely to attract greater competition.

Businesses can also consider using premium savings to strengthen their protection. This may include increasing coverage limits, improving policy terms or investing in measures that reduce the likelihood and financial impact of future losses.

Australia remains a buyers' market for commercial insurance. However, falling premiums should not be mistaken for falling risk.

Businesses that use current conditions to better understand their exposures and strengthen their insurance arrangements will be better placed to manage future claims costs and changes in the insurance market.

1 https://www.aon.com/en/insights/reports/global-insurance-market-insights/q3-2026-overview