The Times Australia
Google AI
The Times World News

.

Is it possible to ‘objectively’ judge music? We asked 5 experts

  • Written by Sam Whiting, Lecturer - Creative Industries, University of South Australia
Is it possible to ‘objectively’ judge music? We asked 5 experts

Everyone has a favourite band, or a favourite composer, or a favourite song. There is some music which speaks to you, deeply; and other music which might be the current big hit, but you can only hear nails on a chalkboard.

Every time a major artist releases their new album, the critics are there to tell you exactly how the artist got it right – or how they got it wrong. And the fans are there to tell the critic how they got it right or wrong, in turn.

So if we all have our own opinions on music, is it ever possible to judge it objectively? Or are we all subject to our subjective disagreements forever?

We asked five music experts to let us know what they thought. Here’s what they had to say.

Read more: Taylor Swift's The Tortured Poets Department and the art of melodrama[1]

Read more: Why do we stop exploring new music as we get older?[2]

Read more https://theconversation.com/is-it-possible-to-objectively-judge-music-we-asked-5-experts-227899

Times Magazine

IPECS Phone System in 2026: The Future of Smart Business Communication

By 2026, business communication is no longer just about making and receiving calls. It’s about speed...

With Nvidia’s second-best AI chips headed for China, the US shifts priorities from security to trade

This week, US President Donald Trump approved previously banned exports[1] of Nvidia’s powerful ...

Navman MiVue™ True 4K PRO Surround honest review

If you drive a car, you should have a dashcam. Need convincing? All I ask that you do is search fo...

Australia’s supercomputers are falling behind – and it’s hurting our ability to adapt to climate change

As Earth continues to warm, Australia faces some important decisions. For example, where shou...

Australia’s electric vehicle surge — EVs and hybrids hit record levels

Australians are increasingly embracing electric and hybrid cars, with 2025 shaping up as the str...

Tim Ayres on the AI rollout’s looming ‘bumps and glitches’

The federal government released its National AI Strategy[1] this week, confirming it has dropped...

The Times Features

Australians Can Choose Their Supermarket — But Have Little Independence With Electricity

Australians can choose where they shop for groceries. If one supermarket lifts prices, reduces q...

Sweeten Next Year’s Australia Day with Pure Maple Syrup

Are you on the lookout for some delicious recipes to indulge in with your family and friends this ...

Operation Christmas New Year

Operation Christmas New Year has begun with NSW Police stepping up visibility and cracking down ...

FOLLOW.ART Launches the Nexus Card as the Ultimate Creative-World Holiday Gift

For the holiday season, FOLLOW.ART introduces a new kind of gift for art lovers, cultural supporte...

Bailey Smith & Tammy Hembrow Reunite for Tinder Summer Peak Season

The duo reunite as friends to embrace 2026’s biggest dating trend  After a year of headlines, v...

There is no scientific evidence that consciousness or “souls” exist in other dimensions or universes

1. What science can currently say (and what it can’t) Consciousness in science Modern neurosci...

Brand Mentions are the new online content marketing sensation

In the dynamic world of digital marketing, the currency is attention, and the ultimate signal of t...

How Brand Mentions Have Become an Effective Online Marketing Option

For years, digital marketing revolved around a simple formula: pay for ads, drive clicks, measur...

Macquarie Capital Investment Propels Brennan's Next Phase of Growth and Sovereign Tech Leadership

Brennan, a leading Australian systems integrator, has secured a strategic investment from Macquari...