Business Blockbuster - Helpng business to be more visible on Google
The Times Australia

First Past the Post: Would It Work in Australia?

  • Written by: The Times

Would First Past The Post voting work in Australia

Every federal election brings renewed debate about Australia's voting system. Most Australians have grown up with preferential voting for the House of Representatives, yet many democracies—including the United Kingdom, the United States and Canada—still use some form of "first past the post" voting.

Would such a system work in Australia? And if it did, would it produce fairer governments?

Under a first past the post system, the candidate with the most votes wins, even if they receive less than 50 per cent of the vote. If five candidates contest an electorate and the winner receives 38 per cent of the vote, they are elected. There is no distribution of preferences.

Australia abandoned that approach for federal elections more than a century ago. Preferential voting was introduced in 1918 after conservative parties found themselves competing against each other, allowing Labor candidates to win seats despite not attracting majority support. The new system enabled like-minded parties to exchange preferences rather than split the vote.

That history remains relevant today.

Supporters of first past the post argue it is simple. Voters choose one candidate, counting is straightforward and the result is immediately understood. Preference negotiations disappear, and political parties cannot rely on preference deals to help them secure seats.

Critics, however, point out that simplicity comes at a cost.

Imagine an electorate where the vote is divided as follows:

  • Candidate A: 37%
  • Candidate B: 33%
  • Candidate C: 20%
  • Candidate D: 10%

Under first past the post, Candidate A wins despite 63 per cent of voters choosing someone else.

Australia's preferential system attempts to solve that problem by redistributing votes according to voters' subsequent preferences until one candidate receives majority support.

Would first past the post make elections fairer?

The answer depends on what Australians believe elections should achieve.

If the goal is to elect the candidate with the largest single block of support, first past the post performs that task efficiently.

If the goal is to ensure every elected member commands majority support after preferences are counted, Australia's existing system has a strong argument in its favour.

Another question concerns strategic voting.

Without preferences, voters may feel pressured to abandon their preferred minor party candidate in favour of a larger party simply to prevent another candidate from winning. Political parties may also adjust their campaign strategies to discourage competitors with similar policies from entering marginal seats, knowing that divided support could hand victory to an opponent.

Australia experienced precisely these concerns before preferential voting was introduced.

Would any Australian government seek to return to first past the post?

Politically, such reform appears unlikely.

Major changes to Australia's electoral system would attract intense parliamentary and public scrutiny. Any proposal would require broad political support, and parties benefiting from the current arrangements would have little incentive to advocate significant change.

Moreover, Australians have become accustomed to preferential voting. It allows voters to support smaller parties and independents without necessarily "wasting" their vote, while still expressing preferences between the major contenders.

The debate nevertheless remains worthwhile.

Electoral systems shape governments, political parties and public confidence in democracy. There is no perfect model. Every voting system involves trade-offs between simplicity, representation, stability and fairness.

As Australia's political landscape becomes increasingly fragmented, questions about how Australians choose their governments are likely to remain part of the national conversation.

Perhaps the most important question is not whether first past the post is better or worse, but what Australians expect their electoral system to achieve.

Australia

Red Bull Aeriality Takes Surfing to New Heights in Perth

Western Australia’s surfers soar at Scarborough Beach, at inaugural Red Bull  Aeriality  MAVERICK WILSON and ISI ...

Starlink prices rise: is reliable internet still affordable for Australians?

Starlink remains a valuable connection for Australians poorly served by other networks. But rising prices expose...

271,004 domain names in a day: the internet’s continuing vote of confidence in enterprise

Somewhere in the world, someone has just thought of a business name and checked whether its internet address is ...

Times Magazine

What is a passkey — and should you use one instead of a password?

Websites increasingly invite users to create a passkey. The unfamiliar name describes a simpler wa...

A quality cut to bills for Beaufort butcher

Victorians are increasingly turning to Easy Electric SEC to better understand their home energy op...

Mentoring - Raising a child is more than providing for one

Food, shelter, safety and schooling are essential. But the guidance children receive about how to ...

Technology

What is a passkey — and should you …

Websites increasingly invite users to create a passkey. The unfamiliar name describes a simpler wa...

Local News

From paediatric nurse to trans-Tasm…

The time-honoured tradition of showing up with a home-cooked meal is getting a modern makeover, wi...

Culture

Head Injuries in Children and Adults: When Im…

Head injury scans are among the most time-critical imaging tests, and also among the most misunderst...

Travel

Jet Skis to Launch Surfers Skyward at Scarbor…

Twenty of WA's most exciting aerial surfers will be towed into waves at speed for Red Bull Aeriali...

The Times Features

Head Injuries in Children and Adults: When Imaging Is C…

Head injury scans are among the most time-critical imaging tests, and also among the most misunderst...

Kinder Unwraps Christmas 2026 with Personalised Santa S…

This Christmas, Kinder is making the festive season even more magical with a range of delicious ch...

Jet Skis to Launch Surfers Skyward at Scarborough Beach

Twenty of WA's most exciting aerial surfers will be towed into waves at speed for Red Bull Aeriali...